| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | ||
| Total Yards: | 7507 1988 Dogs | Total yards: | 4057 1994 Wizards |
| Yards rushing: | 3720 1990 Pachyderms | Yards rushing: | 1572 1995 Pounders |
| Yards passing: | 4700 1995 Pachyderms | Yards passing: | 1991 1989 Mercenaries |
| Points for: | 580 1988 Dogs | Fewest points allowed: | 235 1988 Mercenaries |
| Total point differential | (+/-): | 235 1994 Wizards | |
| Total point differential | (+/-): | +292 1993 Mercenaries | |
| RUSHING | |||
| Rushing yards: | 3066 Bo Jackson | Rushing Touchdowns: | 27 Bo Jackson |
| 1990 Pachyderms | 1988 Dogs | ||
| Average per rush: | 6.7 Neil Anderson | Rushing fumbles: | 18 John Settle |
| (>100 attempts) | 1990 Wizards | (Admitted to) | 1989 Harriers |
| PASSING | |||
| Passing yards: | 4260 Dan Marino | Yards per attempt: | 8.1 Warren Moon |
| 1988 Dogs | (>250 attempts) | 1990 Harriers | |
| Passing attempts: | 642 Joe Montana | Completions: | 381 Joe Montana |
| 1990 Mercenaries | 1990 Mercenaries | ||
| Pass rating: | 91.6 Matt Schaub | Fewest Interceptions: | 6 Ken O'Brien |
| (>250 attempts) | 2009 Titans | (>250 attempts) | 1989 Coons |
| Completion percentage: | 65.3 Wade Wilson | Passing touchdowns: | 39 Dan Marino |
| (>250 attempts) | 1993 Pachyderms | 1994 Jackals | |
| Touchdown percentage: | 8.5 Dan Marino | Interception percentage: | 1.5 Ken O'Brien |
| (>250 attempts) | 1991 Pachyderms | (>250 attempts) | 1989 Coons |
| RECEIVING | |||
| Receiving yards: | 2051John Taylor | Most catches: | 164 Rod Holman |
| 1990 Harriers | 1989 Dogs | ||
| Receiving touchdowns: | 25 Anthony Miller | Yards per catch | 30.2 Andre Reed |
| 1991 Pachyderms | (>50 catches) | 1991 Bandits | |
| SACKS | |||
| Sacks: | 35 Steve McMichael | Sack yards: | 298 Steve McMichael |
| 1993 Mercenaries | 1993 Mercenaries | ||
| Longest Sack | Elvis Dumerville | -22 Yards | Sacked Tony Romo |
| 2015 Hammerheads | |||
| INTERCEPTIONS | |||
| Interceptions: | 20 Anthony Newman | Yards per interception: | 33.7 Anthony Newman |
| 1994 Wizards | 1994 Wizards | ||
| Touchdowns: | |||
| KICK RETURN | |||
| Longest Kick Return: | CJ Spiller | 109 yd, KR for TD vs. PIT | |
| 2015 Harriers |